YOUR READING ASSIGNMENTS
Limited access to this copyrighted material is by explicit permission of the author and only available for this free cost during the active running of this course in 2024. The final version will be available in book format shortly after the conclusion of this course.
Class Agenda Week 7: “The Encroaching Darkness & The Collapse of Boundaries”
Twin Peaks School – Class Agenda for Part Seven of The Return
A welcoming and serious discussion based on JB Minton’s analysis of identity, fear, and the unraveling of reality in Twin Peaks: The Return
Twin Peaks School – Class Agenda for Part Seven of The Return
A welcoming and serious discussion based on JB Minton’s analysis of identity, fear, and the unraveling of reality in Twin Peaks: The Return*
Introduction: The Encroaching Darkness & The Collapse of Boundaries
Part Seven of Twin Peaks: The Return accelerates the unraveling of the dream as fear, memory, and corruption merge into a disturbing landscape. JB Minton’s analysis positions this episode as a meditation on fear, the erosion of identity, and the looming convergence of multiple investigations—all while the dreamer (Cooper) remains lost.
Key Themes for Discussion:
The Lizard Brain vs. The Frontal Cortex – Jerry and Ben Horne’s contrasting states as a reflection of order and chaos.
Fear as the Overriding Force – How dread spreads through Part Seven like an infection.
The Corruption of Memory & Identity – Diane’s confrontation with Mr. C and the revelation of Audrey’s fate.
The Interwoven Investigations – How various agencies are closing in, yet remain blind to the real truth.
The Woodsmen & The Maintenance of the Dream – Are these figures cleaning up the narrative to keep the dreamer trapped?
Scene-by-Scene Breakdown & Discussion Questions
1. Jerry Horne in the Woods: The Lizard Brain in Panic
📍 Key Idea: Jerry’s paranoia mirrors the growing fear in the dream world.
Lost and terrified in the woods, Jerry calls Ben for help but descends into confusion and panic.
Minton argues that Jerry represents the "lizard brain"—pure instinct and fear—while Ben represents the logical "frontal cortex."
This is not just a comedic scene—it sets the emotional tone of the entire episode.
Discussion Questions:
Minton suggests that when we feel frustrated with The Return, we should poll our emotions. How does Jerry’s panic reflect the anxiety of both Cooper and the audience?
Is Jerry lost in a literal sense, or is this another symbol of the dreamer’s disorientation?
What does it mean that Jerry will later witness a "terrible sacrifice"—what role does he play in this world?
🔹 Challenging Statement: “Jerry’s fear is not random—it is a signal that something is terribly wrong in the structure of this reality.”
2. Hawk’s Discovery & The Missing Diary Pages
📍 Key Idea: The corruption of memory is central to The Return
Hawk and Frank Truman uncover missing pages from Laura Palmer’s diary, revealing that Annie appeared to Laura in a dream, warning her that the "good Dale" is still trapped in the Lodge.
The pages were hidden inside a bathroom stall—an absurd yet deeply symbolic location.
Minton argues that this scene connects The Return to Fire Walk With Me—suggesting it’s all part of the same evolving nightmare.
Discussion Questions:
If Laura never met Cooper, what does it mean that she communicates with him in dreams?
Why were the pages hidden in such an unremarkable location? Is this another example of the dream manipulating memory?
Minton points out that Frank Truman doesn’t ask about Annie’s fate. Is this an oversight, or is the dream suppressing the answer?
🔹 Challenging Statement: “The dream will never allow Cooper to find his way out—it will always erase, suppress, and confuse key truths.”
3. The Corruption of Diane & The Manipulation of Memory
📍 Key Idea: Diane’s confrontation with Mr. C reveals deep trauma and deception.
Diane meets Mr. C in prison and immediately knows: "That is not the Dale Cooper I knew."
Yet Mr. C’s voice sounds programmed as if he is manipulating Diane rather than answering her.
Minton suggests that this scene is not just about deception—it’s about programming. Is Mr. C planting a psychological "time bomb" inside Diane?
Discussion Questions:
Minton describes Diane as a "vessel of suffering and seething rage." How has her memory of Cooper been manipulated?
Mr. C never directly answers Diane’s questions—he only echoes her statements. Is this evidence that he is "rewriting" her mind?
Gordon and Albert immediately trust Diane’s reaction. Why is emotional intuition more reliable than evidence in The Return?
🔹 Challenging Statement: “Diane is not just traumatized—she is being used as a weapon inside Cooper’s dream.”
4. The Woodsmen: Enforcers of the Dream
📍 Key Idea: Are the Woodsmen maintaining this reality by erasing threats?
When Major Briggs’ body is discovered, a Woodsman appears in the morgue, lingering ominously.
Minton compares Woodsmen to "white blood cells" in a dream world, erasing anything threatening the narrative.
The electric hum builds as the Woodsman watches and listens but does not act.
Discussion Questions:
If the Woodsmen are "janitors" of the dream, why do they erase certain people but not others?
Are the Woodsmen passive observers, or are they waiting for the right moment to intervene?
What does it mean that electricity grows stronger when the Woodsmen appear?
🔹 Challenging Statement: “The Woodsmen are not villains—they are enforcers of the rules that keep this world functioning.”
5. Mr. C’s Escape: The Power of Corruption
📍 Key Idea: Corruption is the key to power in this world.
Mr. C blackmails Warden Murphy, securing his release with just a few whispered names.
Minton describes corruption as the true power structure of this world—not justice, not law, but who controls the dirtiest secrets.
The "dog leg" motif symbolizes how corruption festers inside this dream layer.
Discussion Questions:
Why does the Warden immediately give in to Mr. C? Is this proof that fear is the true power in The Return?
Minton describes corruption as the "choke point where good intention meets society." Does this scene prove that resistance is futile?
What does the "dog leg" symbolize in this scene? Why does it keep appearing throughout The Return?
🔹 Challenging Statement: “In The Return, corruption is the only system that actually works.”
6. The Great Northern’s Ringing Tone & The Mystery of Room 315
📍 Key Idea: The past is reawakening—slowly but surely.
Ben Horne and Beverly Paige search for the source of a mysterious hum inside the Great Northern.
Beverly discovers Cooper’s old room key, bringing it back into the narrative after decades.
Minton suggests that the hum is a signal from Cooper’s past, calling him back to himself.
Discussion Questions:
Is the humming noise trying to wake Cooper up? Or is it another trick of the dream?
Does Ben Horne remember Cooper, or is this just a random moment of nostalgia?
Why does The Return repeatedly show memory as a fractured, unreliable force?
🔹 Challenging Statement: “The past is alive in Twin Peaks—but only in fragments, echoes, and whispers.”
Final Reflection: Can the Dream Be Broken?
What is the biggest threat to this dream world—Cooper’s awakening or something else?
Is the narrative tightening around Cooper, or is he still drifting deeper into illusion?
🔹 Final Thought Exercise:
If you were inside Cooper’s dream, what would be the first clue that something was wrong?
Next class… "Part Eight”
Support This Community With A Paid Subscription and Share Your Thoughts On Twin Peaks With Other Good People. Every Comment Gets a Response.
AI DISCLAIMER: This podcast was produced using Google’s NotebookLM, but I put a lot of work into the prompting, and I think it has accomplished a great job of the goal I asked it to perform.
Share this post